Accountability should be thought of in two ways: accountability to whom and accountability for what. In terms of whom, three groups—funders, staff, and beneficiaries and communities—expect nonprofits to be accountable to them. Accountability for what includes finances and governance, which focus on compliance, and performance and mission, which are about demonstrating short and long term progress toward addressing social problems. Accountability can actually be made strategic by seeking and sharing information to help a nonprofit achieve its long-term goals.
Since the public expects higher ethical standards from nonprofits than commercial organizations, falling short on either accountability or mission can lead to diminished impact and organizational collapse. In the face of limited financial and human resources, how can nonprofit leaders balance accountability efforts and mission-focused work?

Assess trust levels

Making wise decisions about allocating resources to mission or accountability is easier when nonprofit leaders have a pulse on public trust towards their organization and the sector broadly. Free annual reports on trust, like the one from Independent Sector (2025), and news articles about nonprofits scandals are readily available and provide easy ways to stay informed. To find out how much people trust your organization, consider asking them directly. Be open to taking action based on feedback, as this kind of participation strengthens accountability to the community.

Share successes widely

Nonprofit leaders can advance mission and accountability simultaneously by demonstrating the societal good done by a nonprofit and communicating those successes widely. Silence is corrosive when it comes to public trust, so regularly share with the public strong reasons to trust your organization. Communicating with your closest donors should be paired with messages geared toward the wider public. Nonprofits should also encourage fellow organizations to publicize their wins because the positive reputation of nonprofits within the community will strengthen all groups.

Mind the accountability gaps

It is typical for nonprofits to be most accountable to those with financial power over the organization. To avoid paying disproportionate attention to funders, strengthen how your organization demonstrates accountability to beneficiaries and community members. Consider holding or participating in community gatherings where you present information about your nonprofit’s activities to the public. If your organization already does that, consider ways of furthering community collaboration, like transferring some decision-making authority over projects to beneficiaries.

Build compliance into workflows

Being compliant with requirements imposed by regulators and funders is the baseline of accountability for nonprofits. Take advantage of the fact that these are explicitly stated and rarely change to educate staff on the relevant requirements, like completion of the federal Form 990 and state registrations required for charitable solicitation. Then, make it easy for staff to successfully fulfill the requirements by breaking down the work into manageable steps, assigning responsibilities, and explaining how each task contributes to the nonprofit’s demonstration of accountability. Consider writing expectations for contributions to accountability efforts into job descriptions to maximize clarity for staff.

Expand accountability through learning and innovation

Nonprofit leaders should coach their teams to think of accountability as more than a check-the-box exercise. Reframing accountability measures as strategies that enhance the organization’s ability to deliver its mission breaks down the zero-sum mentality of mission versus accountability. The only way to increasingly improve how a nonprofit delivers its mission is to build in processes of learning and innovating. Insights gained should be shared across the nonprofit to unify everyone in the shared effort of getting better at, and being accountable for, mission.

Nonprofit stakeholders demand and deserve excellence from the organizations they support and rely upon in both mission-driven work and accountability efforts. That level of excellence is challenging to achieve, but is attainable through thoughtful planning, steady commitment, and a courageous willingness to learn.

Emma S. Anderson is a 2025 graduate of the Master of Nonprofit Leadership and Management program at Arizona State University. She works as the Program Manager and Customer Service Manager at Children’s Cancer Research Fund, leading change and strengthening processes for a national nonprofit fueling transformational research to bring better treatments and cures to children with cancer. Outside of work, she enjoys cheering on the sports teams of the places she’s called home, Minnesota and Toronto.

Image created with Canva Image Generator

Lead your organization with accountability with the Nonprofit Management Certificate

Transform your career and your community with the Nonprofit Management Certificate. This program is designed for professionals who want to lead with impact in the nonprofit sector, whether you're a seasoned nonprofit professional ready to advance or a career switcher seeking purpose over profits.

You'll learn how to maximize a nonprofit organization’s staff, resources and day-to-day operations and add value to your professionalism through certified competency from the ASU Lodestar Center's Nonprofit Management Institute.

• Turning scarcity into strategy: How small nonprofits can maximize impact with limited resources
• How volunteer leadership strategies strengthen nonprofit sustainability